James Gunn’s new Superman movie is stirring up a storm even before its official release on July 11, 2025. The film’s review embargo was set to lift on July 8, but several early reviews have already leaked online, sparking heated debate among fans and critics.
The earliest leaked review came from The Daily Beast. It was highly critical, calling the movie “terrible” and the “final nail in the coffin” for superhero films.
The review slammed the film for being overloaded with CGI and chaotic action scenes that lose impact. It also criticized David Corenswet, The new Superman, saying he is overshadowed by past actors like Christopher Reeve and Henry Cavill.
The review argued that the film tries to juggle too many characters and plots, which weakens the main story and character development. This review was quickly taken down but before it caused significant online backlash.
In contrast, The Sunday Times published a very positive review. The paper described Superman as a “much-needed triumph” for DC Studios. Their critic praised James Gunn’s direction and even called this version of Superman the best since Christopher Reeve. This highlights a hopeful future for the DC cinematic universe under Gunn’s leadership.
Variety also shared some early impressions, though less detailed. Their initial comment suggested that the comedy film “Heads of State” might be more enjoyable than Superman. However, they have not released a full review yet.
The leaks have caused confusion and debate. Some fans and insiders argue that the negative reviews do not reflect the general audience’s feelings. Others believe the early negative reviews were intentional to generate buzz.
A critic defending the movie compared the experience to the joy of watching “Top Gun: Maverick,” calling it one of the happiest movie outings in recent years.
The embargo break has also raised concerns about the impact on the film’s release. Studios usually set embargoes to control the timing and flow of reviews to build anticipation. Leaks like these can shape public opinion prematurely and create divisions among fans before the movie is widely seen.
Although Superman (2025) is facing a mixed reception before it even opens, it threatens. Early leaked reviews range from harsh criticism of its CGI and storytelling to high praise for its fresh take on the iconic hero.
With the official reviews now public, the film is poised to be one of the most talked about and divisive superhero movies of the year. Fans will have to wait until July 11 to see if the movie lives up to the hype or falls short of expectations.
